Upper Case, lower case“Sometimes the things that may or may not be true are the things a man needs to believe in the most. That people are basically good; that honor, courage, and virtue mean everything; that power and money, money and power mean nothing; that good always triumphs over evil; and I want you to remember this, that love... true love never dies. You remember that, boy. You remember that. Doesn't matter if it's true or not. You see, a man should believe in those things, because those are the things worth believing in.”
love is something you wake up to every morning, both petrified and exhilarated by the incredible risk and rush of its giddy head, drawn in by the sweet soft whispers and storming fury alike. it is equally terrifying as it is edifying, and it is anything but certain.
i first met katie just more than two years ago; our friendship was a thing of fierce beauty, wild like a tiger and playful like a puppy. almost immediately, we were drawn to spending as much time with each other as possible, intoxicated by the joy we found in each others' company and our many adventures. wrestling in fields and living rooms, running through prairies, climbing bluffs, water towers, and rock walls, we were drunk with each other.
and we both thought we were just friends. at graduation, the hardest parting was with katie. we'd barely gotten to know each other, it seemed, and the possibilities for our adventures together seemed limitless. she was off to her chicago suburb, where she planned to spend the summer continuing to look for teaching positions. i was to spend the summer in decorah, working whatever job i found to pass the time until my "real job" as a naturalist began in the fall, running as many miles as i could and just generally enjoying one last summer of responsibility-free life.
i thought of her frequently, and sent her a few emails and more IMs. she admitted that she missed me too, and together we hatched a plan: she and her sister would come visit us in decorah, and a whole group of us would spend the weekend camping, kayaking, and canoing. it was perfect.
as the weekend approached, it was nearly all i talked of; several of my coworkers asked me repeatedly to stop. i couldn't help it – i was just too excited. the weekend itself was everything we could have hoped for – good weather, good friends, and all in all, a great time. floating down the river, we told jokes and waged water wars. everyone but katie and i got a little annoyed with all of it, but we were oblivious.
back at camp that night, we played frisbee and drank and wrestled and chased each other through the field and down the road. that night, we spooned. at the time, it just felt right. i didn't even think about the fact that i had a girlfriend, and neither, i think, did katie. after all, we were just really good friends.
that weekend i convinced katie to apply for the same naturalist position i had already accepted. when she got home, she did; shortly after, she was offered the job, which she accepted. i was both overjoyed and petrified: we were going to be roommates.
at the same time, things with my girlfriend were continuing to rapidly decay. one of my best friends had just disappeared in the mountains, and i wasn't taking it well; i'd never (at least until katie) felt so alive or had so much fun with anyone, and losing him and that vibrant personality put a real damper on the rest of the summer. things with kirstyn only continued to get worse.
at the tail end of the summer, kirstyn and i took two weeks to visit some friends and climb some mountains out west. it was a rocky trip; twice she offered to pull over on the side of the interstate and let me hitch a ride home.
the fall came quickly, and with it, the move to the environmental education center where katie and i would spend the year. she got their first, and had already chosen a suite for us. though i was a little apprehensive about rooming with a girl, kirstyn urged me ahead. besides, she said, i already knew katie and i would get along.
the fall blazed ahead, with late social nights and early morning miles. every couple of weeks i ran the forty-five miles on friday night or saturday morning to visit kirstyn; she gave me a ride back on sunday. nearly four years together, things were unraveling worse and worse.
at the same time, katie and i were having the adventures of our lives. we wrestled and rock climbed and spent hours on the high rope treetop courses. we went for long hikes and built fires. we spooned on a regular basis, every time we drank, really -- but still saw each other as friends, and didn't see anything strange about this. our eyes still unopened, the beginning of a fairytale was lost on us; we were not yet aware of the magic building before us. everyone else saw it -- nearly every day someone would ask me what was going on between katie and i. people just saw us and assumed.
kirstyn and i broke up. it was messy and awkward and something i didn't do particularly well. one night, laying in her bed and chatting lazily, in that perfectly comfortable space where two bodies fit just as they should, i kissed katie. she kissed back. we were both in shock, and spent the rest of the night wide awake.
we talked into the wee hours and then picked up the conversation the next day. friends with benefits we decided – it didn't make sense to do something stupid and jeopardize this wonderful friendship. and so, for a while, that's how we left it. we told no one, but even our families were beginning to ask what the real story was between us.
somewhere in the course of those magical weeks, things shifted. we both knew we couldn't continue pretending to just be friends. i fell hard. the magic of our time together was just so intoxicating, so powerful. as winter developed and moved towards spring, we began making plans for the next year. whereas once i had planned on returning to my love of the west, losing myself back in mountains and the infinite sky, i knew that i had to be with katie. to pass on this sort of magic, to not take the chance and let it develop as it might – that would be wrong, and something i'd have to regret the rest of my life. love, i decided, was always worth the risk.
i'd already applied a few places out west; i turned down a naturalist position in california and a backpacking/naturalist position in oregon. i didn't know what the future held, but i knew katie would be a part of it.
winter melted into spring, slowly and not without a few parting shots (a major storm at the end of february, some serious cold). sap collection began, and somehow it seemed katie and i were always the ones assigned it. between that and developing an orienteering course, we spent long hours – whole days even – tramping through the woods together on our snowshoes, atop several feet of snow. i introduced her to a longtime favorite sport, the knocking over of dead trees; we had snowball fights and made out under lightly dusted branches.
she began looking for teaching jobs; i began looking for anything i was qualified for. in february, she had a girls weekend with some friends in the cities; one of her best friends was looking for a roommate. now she had a place to stay.
spring got busy, and as summer approached, we were still both jobless. i crashed in my brother's dorm room; she went home for a while, and then on vacation with her family. after a couple of weeks, i found a place near hers that wasn't too pricey, and moved in.
she moved up the end of june, and the magic picked up all over again, despite the fact that neither of us had jobs. we went for bike rides, ran and roller-bladed around the lakes, lost ourselves in farmers market after farmers market. we made great meals, and even joined a cooking club.
katie interviewed for several teaching positions. they all went well to varying degrees, but she struggled to find a job she was happy with. i interviewed for everything imaginable: food service, food prep, library page, copywriting, community organization, tutoring and mentoring. at the end of july, i accepted at my current position, working in an alternative high school in one of the suburbs. not long after, katie accepted a position as a long-term sub (the entire year) for a second grade classroom in another suburb. i found a new place to live, not wanting to commute eighteen miles each way on bike or foot everyday.
the school year started, and both of us were busy and stressed. still, we saw each other at least once or twice during the week, catching dinner, maybe a little bit of tv and some hard z's. weekends were slightly more restful. life was wearing, but with other, it was still just as rejuvenating as that first spring. i began to see a wonderful future.
sometime in november, i think katie began to realize i was serious about wanting to marry her someday; it freaked her out. still, we talked about meeting the rest of each others' relatives at christmas, and began to discuss getting an apartment together when our current leases ran out in june. we were in this for the long haul, waiting to see where it would take us.
christmas plans fell through. katie told me it just wasn't practical this year, but i knew that more than anything, that really meant she wasn't ready for this to be that serious. we talked about this, discussed the future. ever the seven-year old (for better and for worse), she nearly broke up with me, scared by something so adult. we talked more, and as january came through, i made serious efforts to back off, let things develop in a way that was less frightening to her. the magic still shone, and she relaxed, opened back up.
i made plans towards my teaching license and driving license and all those sorts of big adult decisions. we continued to discuss getting an apartment together, though, not wanting to frighten her, i let her guide those conversations as much as possible.
we still (neither one of us) had much in the way of job security for this summer and into next year, but we began to look at apartment listings based on where we hoped to be. we found several nice listings that sounded like they would work for both of us; exactly a week ago katie called and made several appointments – we were going to go looking over the weekend.
thursday night i fell asleep before my customary goodnight conversation with katie; she called twice before i woke. still mostly asleep, we had a short conversation; i fell asleep midsentence, as i occasionally did (i wear myself pretty ragged sometimes). friday morning, i called her early, on my way into work. she kept the conversation brief, and sounded upset about something. i figured we'd talk about it that evening, when we met to start the weekend.
friday was a pretty normal day; school came and went. i started a load of laundry and got some after school miles in before katie came over. she was early – very early even for a rough week – and she was crying a little when she got to my place. i imagined it had been a rough day at school, and asked her about it.
"matt," she said, "i think we need to break up and just be friends." we talked for a little while, but it was clear she had already decided and there wasn't going to be much of a conversation; she packed up everything of hers at my place and drove off.
out on a run, i stopped by her place saturday morning; we talked for a little while before she asked me to leave. since then i've done as she requested and given her her space; i'll hear from her when she decides she's ready.
until then, it's a waiting game. i know what i want: her. it's not a hard equation for me. love is about taking that risk, and i chose long ago that the risk was always worth it; no matter how pain it may cause, real love is always worth the trouble. if we fall, we fall; i know i am strong, and will get back up.
i also know katie. odds aren't good that we'll get back together. she's not much of a risk-taker, and she'd prefer to stay as much a kid as possible. this relationship isn't good for either of those desires. i'm realistic.
one person can never love enough to carry two, and i'm not foolish enough to try. but neither am i foolish enough to let the best thing that's ever happened to me slip out of my life. with kirstyn, i made some big mistakes, and it cost me a great friend and several good ones. i will not repeat those mistakes with katie.
things are likely to be awkward for sometime, regardless of what happens from here. i'm aware of that likelihood. and i know that for every step forward, there will likely be a corresponding step back. but i refuse to lose track of the moment. the future isn't here yet, and the past is long gone; there is only now. i can only control my choices, my actions. so i choose to love.
several of you have been a great help these past few days; you know you are, and you are wise, kind souls. the world is a better place for each of you, and i thank you for that. it's wednesday, hump day. life goes on.